It sounds like your DNS records for the dedicated sending domain aren’t fully verified. When Klaviyo disconnects a sending domain, it’s almost always because at least one of the DNS records (CNAMEs) no longer matches what Klaviyo expects.
Here’s what to check:
-
Re-verify all 3 CNAME records in GoDaddy (they must match exactly what Klaviyo provides — host, value, and TTL).
-
Make sure no extra prefixes were added by GoDaddy (e.g., domain.com.domain.com).
-
DNS propagation can take time, but 4 days is long — this usually means the records were entered incorrectly or overwritten.
-
After fixing the records, go back to Klaviyo → Settings → Domains → Verify.
If the CNAMEs are correct, the domain will reconnect immediately. Your replies will start working again once the domain is verified.